“Your assumptions are your windows on the world. Scrub them off every once in a while, or the light won’t come in.” — Isaac Asimov
Shut up and sing. Or write. Or play. Or any other occupation…
That’s a favorite phrase among a certain kind of folks nowadays. Of course, what those folks really mean is “shut up…if you don’t agree with me.”
Now, there’s a belief out there that it is conservatives that embody that drive. And, to a certain extent, there is a strong element of that among the more vocal and rabid “conservatives”. But, just as much, the same belief and impulse holds true on the left. Liberals can point to talk radio hosts and TV talking-heads, but conservatives can point just as much to college campuses and, well, more TV talking-heads. And me? I point to (pretty much) all of them.
And, no, it is NOT worthwhile to get into the tit-for-tat bullshit of “Well, they did it first!’
“No, THEY did it first!”
“Well, you’re a poopy-pants!”
“No, YOU’RE a poopy-pants!”
Is it any wonder why the most hated professions in the world are politicians and reporters*? Even lawyers rank above them, for pete’s sake…
*To which I will add media talking-heads & “political-pundits”.
Let’s put this argument to rest right now: art, and especially writing, has always played a political role…and it always will. Most often — and worse, to those who hate & fear voices that do not toe their particular line — that role has been to argue against the problems and abuses of the day, according to the artist’s personal perceptions and opinions.
Shit, Shakespeare’s Richard II is one of the most overtly political plays ever written. Virgil’s Aeneid was written as pure political propaganda. The Canterbury Tales had true political significance…Twain…Dickens…Fitzgerald…Wolfe… And that’s just a handful of names, limited for reasons of word-count and space. Hell, if I get into the poets, I could spend a good three seconds of thought and add another hundred names.
But, you know what? Everyone deserves that freedom to express themselves. Not just writers and singers and artists: athletes, and plumbers, and engineers, and astrophysicists….well, maybe not astrophysicists, those folks are freakin’ weird. The point is: if you have an opinion, and sincerely held beliefs, it is not just your right, it is arguably your duty, to behave accordingly. And it is manifestly NOT someone else’s job or right or duty to tell you to “shut up”.*
*And, before you ask (or yell): I fully realize that at-work and at-home are two different things. I am trying to stay high-level and general in this post; I do not want to get into the briar patch complexity of when and where you are “allowed” to express yourself…
Once again, if you don’t like the message, don’t read, or listen, or watch. It’s that simple. Honestly, there are plenty of messages out there that I do not like, and therefore do not “consume”. In the end, Person A cannot compel someone else to toe a specific line of belief or action. But, just the same, Person B cannot compel someone else to agree with, or partake in, their beliefs or actions.
It really is that simple…and it really does go both ways.
No, the “command” to shut up and write (or sing, or play, or whatever) is one of the stupidest and most futile things imaginable. If you don’t like the message, don’t read…or listen, or whatever.
Or, and let’s just try this on for size, YOU could shut up and try to at least envision another point of view. You could try to understand, maybe even to learn.
Or you could live a bubble where the only voices you hear are those that agree with you.
What a miserable world — and life — that would be…and, sadly, pretty much IS right now.
Do you know what we call people who are utterly convinced that their every thought and opinion is 100% sanctified, righteous and correct?
But I repeat myself.